A regular appraisal looks at a house that’s already standing. A new construction appraisal often values a home that is still a set of drawings, a slab or a frame. That changes what the appraiser looks at, when the appraisal happens and what has to be checked again at the end. This guide explains how a new construction appraisal works for Florida buyers using a mortgage or a construction loan, based mainly on Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac rules and federal consumer rules, as of November 2026.
What Makes a New Construction Appraisal Different
When the home isn’t finished, the appraiser can’t walk through it. Fannie Mae’s Selling Guide (section B4-1.2-05, dated December 10, 2025) says that when the property is new or proposed construction, the appraisal must be based on one of these:
- plans and specifications
- an existing model home
- other information sufficient to identify the home’s quality and character
The appraiser then reports the value “subject to” completion per plans and specifications. In plain terms, the value assumes the home will be built the way the documents describe. If the finished home turns out different, the value may not hold.
For construction-to-permanent loans, the number lenders care about is the “as completed” value: what the lot and finished home together are expected to be worth.
Which Rules Apply to Your Loan
Most conventional mortgages follow the Fannie Mae Selling Guide or Freddie Mac’s Seller/Servicer Guide, because lenders often sell those loans to one of the two companies. FHA, VA and USDA loans have their own appraisal and new construction rules. If you’re using one of those programs, ask your lender which requirements apply.
The appraisal forms are changing (UAD 3.6)
For years, most single-family appraisals were reported on Fannie Mae Form 1004 (Freddie Mac Form 70), the Uniform Residential Appraisal Report. Freddie Mac’s UAD and Forms Redesign FAQ says:
- UAD 3.6 is mandatory for new appraisal reports submitted to the GSEs’ Uniform Collateral Data Portal on or after November 2, 2026. The date is tied to when each report is first submitted, not when you applied.
- Form 1004 and the other legacy forms are being replaced by a single, dynamic redesigned report.
- The old Appraisal Update and/or Completion Report (Form 1004D, or Freddie Mac Form 442) becomes two separate reports: a Restricted Appraisal Update Report and a Completion Report.
- A report done on a legacy form still uses the 1004D/442 for updates and completion.
Freddie Mac says the GSEs worked with FHA, USDA and VA on the new dataset, but tells lenders to contact each agency for their own plans. If your appraisal was ordered around the changeover, ask your lender which format your file uses.
How Appraisers Value a Home That Isn’t Built Yet
Comparable sales come first
Fannie Mae requires at least three closed comparable sales in the sales comparison approach (section B4-1.3-08, dated June 4, 2025). For homes in a new subdivision or planned development, the rules add more:
- At least one closed sale from inside the subject subdivision and at least one from outside it.
- A resale is preferred if it can be verified and doesn’t involve the subject builder.
- If the home is one of the first to sell, the appraiser may use two pending sales from the project in place of one closed sale, but then needs at least three closed sales from outside.
- When builder sales from competing projects are used, the report must discuss sales concessions and upgrades compared with the subject home.
Two rules matter a lot if you’re building on your own lot:
- The appraiser may not create a comparable by adding a vacant land sale to the contract price of a home.
- Other construction-to-permanent transactions can’t count toward the three required closed comparables, though they can be added as support.
The cost approach
The cost approach estimates what it would cost to build the home new, then adds the land value. Fannie Mae’s section B4-1.3-10 (dated June 4, 2025) says Fannie Mae doesn’t require it except for manufactured homes. It also says it may be appropriate for new or proposed construction, and that the appraiser must provide it if they believe it’s necessary under USPAP. An appraisal that relies only on the cost approach isn’t acceptable.
So building cost supports the value but doesn’t set it. A home can cost more to build than the market will pay for it, especially with costly custom features.
Land value
The lot is part of the “as completed” value. Appraisers look at recent sales of similar lots and at the features that drive land prices, such as zoning, utilities, flood zone and access. Our guide to how vacant land is valued in Southwest Florida explains those factors in detail.
Who Orders and Pays for the Appraisal
The lender orders it. The FDIC’s consumer guide says your lender will typically order the appraisal and you pay for it as part of the financing process. The fee is one of your closing costs. Our guide to closing costs for home buyers in Florida covers the rest.
You can’t bring your own. Fannie Mae’s section B4-1.1-03 says a lender may not use an appraisal ordered or received by the borrower or other parties with an interest in the transaction, such as the seller or a real estate agent. Lenders may use appraisal management companies to handle appraiser selection.
The appraiser must be independent. Federal Regulation Z (12 CFR 1026.42) covers consumer loans secured by your principal dwelling. It bars lenders, brokers, real estate agents and others from pressuring an appraiser toward a target value or tying the appraiser’s pay to the loan closing. The same rule says it is not a violation to ask the appraiser to:
- consider additional, appropriate property information
- provide more detail or explanation
- correct errors
In Florida, appraisers are licensed or certified by the state under Chapter 475, Part II of the Florida Statutes.
You get a copy. Under Regulation B (12 CFR 1002.14), for a first-lien loan secured by a dwelling, the lender must give you a copy of each appraisal promptly when it’s completed or three business days before closing, whichever is earlier. You can waive that timing, generally at least three business days before closing. The lender can’t charge you for the copy itself.
Timing: When the Appraisal Happens
When the appraisal happens depends on how you’re financing.
Single-close construction-to-permanent loans. Fannie Mae’s section B5-3.1-02 (dated May 6, 2026) says:
- The appraisal’s effective date can be no more than four months before the construction loan’s note date.
- At completion, the appraiser completes the update and completion report in full, including an appraisal update and the certification of completion.
- If that update shows the value has declined, the lender must get a new appraisal and requalify you using the new loan-to-value ratio.
If you already own the lot, the loan is treated as a limited cash-out refinance, and the loan-to-value is based on the “as completed” appraised value of the lot and home. Our guide to construction loans for new homes in Florida explains how that works.
Buying from a builder with a regular mortgage. Fannie Mae’s section B4-1.2-04 (dated June 4, 2025) says the home must be appraised within 12 months before the note date. If the appraisal’s effective date is more than four months old at closing, the appraiser must do an update. If the value has dropped, a new appraisal is required. This matters when construction runs long.
When the Appraisal Comes In Low
An “appraisal gap” is the difference between your contract price and a lower appraised value. For a single-close construction-to-permanent purchase, for example, Fannie Mae’s section B5-3.1-02 measures loan-to-value against the lower of the purchase price or the “as completed” appraised value. Lenders commonly work the same way on other purchases, so a gap usually means you need more cash or a different deal.
Common ways buyers and builders respond, depending on the contract and the lender:
- Review the report. The FDIC suggests checking it closely for errors or missing information, and asking your lender early whether it has a reconsideration of value process and what information it needs.
- Provide better information. Through your lender, you can point out comparable sales or features the appraiser may have missed, such as upgrades that were in the plans.
- Renegotiate. The builder may lower the price or shift money from upgrades.
- Cover the difference. Some buyers pay the gap in cash.
- Change the loan. A larger down payment or a different loan program can change the math.
- Use a contingency. Some contracts let a buyer cancel if the appraisal comes in low. Others don’t, so read yours closely.
Which options you have depends on your contract. Have a Florida real estate attorney review the appraisal and financing terms before you sign, and talk with your lender before you decide anything.
If you believe an appraisal was inaccurate or biased and the lender doesn’t resolve it, the FDIC notes you can file a complaint through HUD or with the lender’s federal regulator.
The Final Inspection and Completion Report
Once the home is finished, the lender needs proof it was built as planned. Fannie Mae’s section B4-1.2-05 lists three ways to document completion per plans and specifications:
- Form 1004D with a site visit by the appraiser.
- Form 1004D with a virtual inspection, using photos, video or other technology.
- A borrower and builder attestation letter, signed and dated by both, confirming the home was built to the plans, specifications, amendments and change orders, with interior and exterior photos. If both signatures can’t be obtained, a Form 1004D is required.
Under UAD 3.6, the completion part moves to its own Completion Report, as noted above.
Sometimes small items can’t be finished before closing. Fannie Mae allows “postponed improvements” in limited cases. They must be finished within 180 days of the note date, can’t exceed 10% of the “as completed” value, and can’t affect the certificate of occupancy. The lender generally holds an escrow of 120% of the estimated cost.
The lender’s completion report is not the same as the building department’s final inspection or certificate of occupancy, and it isn’t a home inspection for your benefit. Our checklist for buying new construction in Southwest Florida covers inspections and the walkthrough.
What Buyers Can Provide
Because the appraiser is valuing documents, better documents help. Give these to your loan officer early, so the lender can pass them along through proper channels:
- Plans and specifications, including the final floor plan, elevations and square footage.
- An upgrade list with costs, such as impact windows, roof type, flooring, cabinetry, pool or outdoor kitchen.
- Change orders signed after the contract.
- Lot details, including the survey, lot size, any lot premium, water frontage and flood zone.
- Energy and storm features, such as insulation, HVAC efficiency, solar or generator.
- HOA or community information, if any.
Don’t contact the appraiser directly to push for a number. Under the independence rules, information should go through the lender.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the appraisal based on my contract price?
No. The appraiser estimates market value from comparable sales and the plans and specifications. The contract price is reviewed, but it doesn’t set the value.
Will my upgrades raise the appraised value?
They can, if the market supports them. Fannie Mae requires appraisers using competing builder sales to discuss upgrades and concessions, but appraisers don’t simply add up what upgrades cost.
Do I need a second appraisal when the house is finished?
Usually there’s a completion report or attestation, not a full new appraisal. A new appraisal may be needed if the original is too old or the update shows the value dropped.
Who sees the appraisal?
You do. Federal rules require the lender to give you a copy at least three business days before closing, unless you waive that timing.
This article is general information, not lending, legal or appraisal advice. Rules differ by loan program and lender, and they change. Confirm details with your lender, a state-licensed appraiser or a Florida real estate attorney.
Planning a New Home?
If you’re comparing plans or getting ready to finance a build, take a look at our home models, then call Proudhouse Builders at (239) 321-0594 or reach us through our contact page. You bring the land, we do the rest.
Sources
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide, B4-1.2-05, Requirements for Verifying Completion and Postponed Improvements (12/10/2025) (plans and specs or model home; “subject to” completion; Form 1004D site visit or virtual inspection; attestation letter; postponed improvements): selling-guide.fanniemae.com/sel/b4-1.2-05/requirements-verif…
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide, B4-1.3-08, Comparable Sales (06/04/2025) (minimum three closed comparables; new subdivision rules; concessions and upgrades; construction-to-permanent comparables; no combining land sales): selling-guide.fanniemae.com/sel/b4-1.3-08/comparable-sales
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide, B4-1.3-10, Cost and Income Approach to Value (06/04/2025): selling-guide.fanniemae.com/sel/b4-1.3-10/cost-and-income-ap…
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide, B4-1.1-03, Appraiser Selection Criteria (06/04/2025) (no borrower-ordered appraisals; appraisal management companies): selling-guide.fanniemae.com/sel/b4-1.1-03/appraiser-selectio…
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide, B4-1.2-04, Appraisal Age and Use Requirements (06/04/2025) (12-month and four-month rules): selling-guide.fanniemae.com/sel/b4-1.2-04/appraisal-age-and-…
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide, B5-3.1-02, Conversion of Construction-to-Permanent Financing: Single-Closing Transactions (05/06/2026) (four-month appraisal age; completion report; value decline; LTV): selling-guide.fanniemae.com/sel/b5-3.1-02/conversion-constru…
- Freddie Mac, UAD and Forms Redesign FAQs (November 2, 2026 mandate; legacy forms retired; 1004D/442 split into update and completion reports; FHA/VA/USDA): sf.freddiemac.com/faqs/uad-and-forms-redesign
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Regulation Z, 12 CFR 1026.42, Valuation Independence: consumerfinance.gov/rules-policy/regulations/1026/42/
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Regulation B, 12 CFR 1002.14, Rules on Providing Appraisals and Other Valuations: consumerfinance.gov/rules-policy/regulations/1002/14/
- FDIC, Understanding Appraisals and Why They Matter (June 2023) (lender orders, borrower pays; reconsideration of value; complaints): fdic.gov/consumer-resource-center/2023-06/understanding-appr…
- Florida Statutes §475.612 (who may issue appraisals), 2026: flsenate.gov/Laws/Statutes/2026/475.612
Own land in Southwest Florida?
Our team can tell you what your parcel can become. Call (239) 321-0594 or start a land review online.
Start a land review


