A Florida roof has to handle hurricane winds, heavy summer rain and intense sun, and it can affect what you pay for insurance. Three common choices for new homes are standing-seam metal, architectural (dimensional) asphalt shingles, and concrete or clay tile. This guide compares them on code rules, wind performance, what happened in Hurricane Ian, lifespan, heat, weight, insurance and upkeep.
The Three Options in Brief
- Standing-seam metal: long metal panels running from ridge to eave, joined at raised seams.
- Architectural (dimensional) shingles: layered asphalt shingles nailed to the roof deck.
- Concrete or clay tile: heavy tiles fastened mechanically or with approved adhesive or mortar over an underlayment.
Any of the three can meet Florida’s code when the product is approved for the home’s design wind speed and installed to its approval.
Florida Product Approval and Wind Ratings
Section 553.842 of the Florida Statutes names roofing, along with windows, doors, shutters and other products, among the categories that must go through the state’s product approval system. A product with statewide approval doesn’t need more local testing if it’s used within the limits of its approval.
Approved products have an FL number you can look up on the Florida Building Commission’s product approval site (floridabuilding.org) to see the code edition and installation limits. Ask your builder for the FL numbers of the roof covering and underlayment.
Shingles. Asphalt shingles must be rated for wind. A UL Solutions evaluation report filed with Florida’s product approval system (February 2024) explains that shingles tested under ASTM D3161 are classified Class F and those tested under ASTM D7158 are classified Class H, and ties those ratings to Section R905.2.6.1 of the 2023 Florida Building Code, Residential, which matches shingle classes to design wind speed.
Tile. In Florida, concrete and clay tile is installed under the FRSA/TRI Florida High Wind Concrete and Clay Roof Tile Installation Manual, a joint manual from the Florida Roofing and Sheet Metal Contractors Association and the Tile Roofing Institute. The code points to it for tile underlayment, and the manual was updated for the higher roof wind loads adopted in the 7th Edition (2020) code.
Metal. Standing-seam panels are approved as a system: the panel, its clips, fastener spacing and the deck it goes over. A panel is only as strong as the attachment listed in its approval.
What’s Under the Roof Matters Too
Roof deck attachment
The roof deck (plywood or OSB sheathing) is nailed to the trusses. A June 2020 fact sheet on the 7th Edition (2020) Florida Building Code, posted by Columbia County, explains that the code requires ring shank nails for roof sheathing and sets the sheathing thickness by wind speed and exposure in Table R803.2.2. That table is still in the 8th Edition (2023) code: for trusses at 24 inches on center, the minimum thickness ranges from 7/16 inch at lower wind speeds up to 19/32 or 23/32 inch at the highest wind speeds and exposures.
Sealed roof deck (secondary water barrier)
The 7th Edition (2020) Florida Building Code made a sealed roof deck standard outside the High-Velocity Hurricane Zone, which doesn’t include Southwest Florida. The same fact sheet says this matches what the Insurance Institute for Business & Home Safety (IBHS) recommends, because a sealed deck can greatly reduce water entry after the roof covering blows off. Its three main options:
- A self-adhering polymer-modified bitumen underlayment (ASTM D1970) over the entire roof.
- Self-adhering strips or approved flashing tape over every joint in the roof deck, with an approved underlayment over the whole roof.
- Two layers of approved felt or synthetic underlayment, lapped and fastened as specified.
Shingles and metal may use any of the three; tile follows the FRSA/TRI manual. The code has been revised since, so ask which option your home uses.
Replacing a roof later
Section 553.844 of the Florida Statutes calls for roof replacements to include deck-attachment and secondary water barrier techniques, and in some cases roof-to-wall connections. The 2020 fact sheet notes the code’s re-roofing mitigation section exempts structures permitted under the Florida Building Code. Under subsection (5), if a roof was built or replaced to the 2007 Florida Building Code or later and 25% or more of it is being repaired or replaced, only the part being worked on must meet the current code. Local governments can’t change that exception.
How Each Performed in Hurricane Ian
Hurricane Ian made landfall at Cayo Costa as a Category 4 storm on September 28, 2022, according to a University of Florida report to the Florida Building Commission. That makes it the most relevant recent test for homes in Lee and Charlotte counties.
IBHS studied roof covers in Southwest Florida after Ian. Its 2023 findings (Giammanco, Newby and Pogorzelski) report:
- Shingles: about half of all shingle roofs had issues, and roofs 10 or more years old were especially vulnerable.
- Tile: about 40% had some damage, but significant damage was rare except on roofs more than 20 years old.
- Metal: damage rates were around 12%, metal systems held up well in winds below 130 mph, and most metal-roof issues came from nearby structures failing, not from the roofs themselves.
FEMA reached a similar conclusion on age. The ICC’s February 2024 summary of FEMA’s Ian report (FEMA P-2342) says newer roof coverings generally performed better than older ones, with hips and ridges the most common damage point. A January 2024 Miami Herald report on the FEMA study said 90% of roofs installed before 2015 in the study sample were damaged, compared with 28% of roofs installed after 2015, and that metal panel roofs didn’t follow the same pattern as asphalt.
FEMA’s 2005 coastal fact sheet on tile adds that tile is very vulnerable to windborne debris, one broken tile can start a cascading failure, and mortar-set tiles, especially at hips and ridges, are more prone to damage. It recommends stainless steel straps, fasteners and clips within 3,000 feet of the ocean.
Takeaway: roof age and installation quality mattered for every material.
How Long Each Lasts
Lifespan claims for roofing vary widely, and many come from marketing. The most neutral source we found is NAHB’s Study of Life Expectancy of Home Components (2007), a national survey of manufacturers, trade groups and researchers. It estimated:
- Asphalt shingles: about 20 years.
- Clay or concrete tile: over 50 years, listed as “lifetime” in its table.
- Metal: the study lists copper as lifetime but does not give a figure for steel standing-seam roofs.
NAHB stresses that roof life depends on local weather, design, material quality and maintenance, and that its figures are not a guarantee. A national average may not match Florida conditions. Ask for the manufacturer’s written warranty, including wind coverage, and read the conditions.
Heat and Energy Use
In Florida, roof color and reflectance matter more than the material name.
A study by the Florida Solar Energy Center (FSEC) for Florida Power & Light used six identical new Habitat for Humanity homes in Fort Myers, built with help from Habitat for Humanity of Lee County, each with a different roof. FPL’s February 2001 summary reported annual cooling savings compared with dark gray shingles of about 23% for white galvanized metal, 20% for white S-shaped tile, 17% for white flat tile, 4% for white shingles and 3% for terra cotta tile. It said savings were most strongly influenced by the solar reflectance of the roof.
Later tests at FSEC’s Flexible Roof Facility in Cocoa (2001 results, published 2002) found every alternative roof had lower estimated cooling loads than a dark shingle roof. These studies are 20 to 25 years old, but the lesson holds: reflectance drives the savings.
You may see “ENERGY STAR” on older roofing literature. The Cool Roof Rating Council reports that the ENERGY STAR program for roofing products ended on June 1, 2022. The Council’s Rated Roof Products Directory lists solar reflectance and thermal emittance for roofing products if you want to compare colors. Our article on energy-efficient new homes in Florida covers the energy code more broadly.
Weight and Structure
Tile is much heavier than metal or shingles. A May 2001 article in the Journal of Light Construction gave standard-weight concrete tile at about 9.5 to 12 pounds per square foot and asphalt shingles at 2.5 to 4 pounds per square foot, with lightweight concrete tiles at about 5.5 to 7 pounds. Exact weights depend on the product, so check the manufacturer’s data.
For a new home, this is handled in design: the trusses and walls are engineered for the roof covering on the plans. It matters more if you ever want to switch from shingles or metal to standard tile on an existing home, which can require an engineer’s review. If you think you might want tile later, ask whether the structure is designed for it. Wall type is a separate choice; see our comparison of concrete block and wood frame homes in Florida.
Insurance and Roof Age
The 15-year rule. Section 627.7011(5) of the Florida Statutes says an insurer may not refuse to issue or renew a homeowners policy on a home with a roof less than 15 years old solely because of the roof’s age. For roofs 15 years or older, the insurer must let the homeowner get an inspection by an authorized inspector, at the homeowner’s expense, before requiring replacement. If the inspection shows at least five years of useful life left, the insurer may not refuse coverage solely because of age. Roof age is counted from the last time 100% of the roof was built or replaced. The rule applies to policies issued or renewed on or after July 1, 2022. It limits refusals based solely on roof age; it doesn’t address other underwriting reasons. As of October 2026, a 2026 bill to change this rule (SB 808) died in committee.
Wind mitigation credits. Section 627.0629 requires insurers to offer discounts or credits for features such as roof covering performance and roof strength. The state’s OIR-B1-1802 wind mitigation form, revised in April 2026, records the roof covering, roof deck attachment, roof-to-wall attachment and secondary water resistance. Citizens Property Insurance Corporation says the revised form also gives certain features credit for FORTIFIED Home Roof, Silver and Gold certificates.
What a given policy charges for metal, shingle or tile varies by insurer. We can’t promise savings for any roof type, so ask a licensed agent to quote the actual home. Our article on home insurance for new construction in Florida covers the basics.
Maintenance
- After every storm, look from the ground for missing shingles, lifted or cracked tiles, loose metal trim, and damage at hips and ridges, the damage FEMA’s team saw most often after Ian.
- Tile: replace broken tiles quickly, since FEMA notes one broken tile can lead to more failures.
- Near saltwater: ask about corrosion-resistant fasteners and clips, which FEMA recommends within 3,000 feet of the ocean.
- Keep records: permits and product approvals help with future inspections and insurance.
Matching the Roof to the Home
The right roof depends on budget, look, HOA rules, how long you plan to stay and how much you want to spend upfront versus later. Two of Proudhouse Builders’ upcoming single-story models show the range: the Bari’s plan sheets list a metal roof, and the Napoli’s list dimensional shingles. You can see them on our home models page. For wind rules in general, see our guide to building for hurricanes in Florida.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a metal roof better than shingles in a Florida hurricane?
In Hurricane Ian, IBHS found damage rates of around 12% for metal roofs compared with about half of shingle roofs in Southwest Florida. Roof age also mattered, and newer roofs generally did better.
Does Florida require a sealed roof deck on new homes?
The 7th Edition (2020) Florida Building Code made sealed-roof-deck underlayment options standard outside the High-Velocity Hurricane Zone. Ask your builder which option your home uses under the current code edition.
Can my insurer drop me because my roof is old?
Under section 627.7011(5), an insurer can’t refuse to issue or renew a homeowners policy solely because of the age of a roof under 15 years old. Older roofs get an inspection option. Confirm details with your agent.
How long does a tile roof last compared with shingles?
NAHB’s 2007 national study estimated about 20 years for asphalt shingles and over 50 years for clay or concrete tile. Actual life depends on climate, installation and maintenance.
This article is general information, not engineering, legal or insurance advice. Confirm details with your building department, a licensed roofing contractor and your insurance agent.
Talk With Proudhouse Builders
Deciding between metal, shingles and tile for a new home in Southwest Florida? Proudhouse Builders plans, designs and builds homes in the region and can walk you through the roof options for your plan. Learn more on our services page, call us at (239) 321-0594, or reach out through our contact page. You bring the land, we do the rest.
Sources
- Florida Statutes, Section 553.842 (product evaluation and approval), 2026: flsenate.gov/Laws/Statutes/2026/553.842
- Florida Building Commission, Product Approval search: floridabuilding.org/pr/pr_app_lst.aspx
- UL Solutions Evaluation Report ER2919-01 for TAMKO asphalt shingles, filed as Florida Product Approval FL18355 (February 29, 2024) (ASTM D3161 Class F / D7158 Class H; 2023 FBC-R Section R905.2.6.1): floridabuilding.org/upload/PR_Tech_Docs/FL18355_R12_AE_UL%20…
- “Significant Changes to Roofing Requirements in the 7th Edition (2020) Florida Building Code” (fact sheet, June 2020), posted by Columbia County: columbiacountyfla.com/Downloads/Significant%20Changes%20to%2…
- City of Sebastian, “Florida Building Code 2020 7th Edition Roofing Underlayment Code Changes” (source: Building A Safer Florida, Inc.): cityofsebastian.org/DocumentCenter/View/1174/Roof-Changes-to…
- Florida Building Commission, Staff Analysis, Declaratory Statement DS 2023-044 (quotes 8th Edition (2023) FBC-R Table R803.2.2): floridabuilding.org/fbc/commission/FBC_0124/DEC_Statements/D…
- University of Florida (Prevatt, Gurley) and Auburn University (Roueche), “Survey and Investigation of Buildings Damaged by Category III, IV and V Hurricanes in FY 2022-2023: Hurricane Ian,” interim report to the Florida Building Commission (May 10, 2023): floridabuilding.org/fbc/commission/FBC_0523/Commission/Preva…
- Florida Statutes, Section 553.844 (roof and opening protection; re-roofing), 2026: flsenate.gov/Laws/Statutes/2026/553.844
- Insurance Institute for Business & Home Safety, “Building Performance in SW Florida During Hurricane Ian (2022), Part 1: Roof Cover Assessment” (Giammanco, Newby, Pogorzelski, 2023): ibhs.org/wind/building-performance-in-sw-florida-during-hurr…
- International Code Council, Building Safety Journal, “Hurricane Ian in Florida: A Mitigation Success Story for Building Codes” (February 7, 2024): iccsafe.org/building-safety-journal/bsj-technical/hurricane-…
- FEMA, Hurricane Ian in Florida Mitigation Assessment Team Report, FEMA P-2342 (December 2023): fema.gov/sites/default/files/documents/fema_rm-hurriance-ian…
- WUSF (Miami Herald), “The best upgrade to reduce a home’s hurricane damage? A newer roof, FEMA study finds” (January 20, 2024): wusf.org/weather/2024-01-20/best-upgrade-reduce-homes-hurric…
- FEMA, Home Builder’s Guide to Coastal Construction (FEMA 499, June 2005), Technical Fact Sheet No. 21, Tile Roofing for High-Wind Areas (copy hosted by the Louisiana Department of Energy and Natural Resources): denr.louisiana.gov/assets/docs/energy/programs/residential/c…
- National Association of Home Builders / Bank of America Home Equity, Study of Life Expectancy of Home Components (February 2007): standards.nsf.org/higherlogic/ws/public/download/348/NAHB%20…
- Florida Power & Light, “Energy Study Helps Homeowners Keep Cooling Costs From Going Through The Roof” (February 7, 2001): newsroom.fpl.com/2001-02-07-Energy-Study-Helps-Homeowners-Ke…
- Florida Solar Energy Center, Flexible Roofing Facility: 2001 Summer Test Results, FSEC-CR-1336-02 (Sonne, Parker, Sherwin, 2002): stars.library.ucf.edu/fsec/566
- Cool Roof Rating Council, “ENERGY STAR Roofing Program Sunsets” (June 1, 2022): coolroofs.org/news/energy-star-roofing-program-sunsets
- Journal of Light Construction, “Roofing With Concrete Tile” (May 2001): images.greenbuildingadvisor.com/app/uploads/2019/05/10050116…
- Florida Statutes, Section 627.7011 (roof age, subsection (5)), 2026: flsenate.gov/Laws/Statutes/2026/627.7011
- Florida Senate, SB 808 (2026), bill history: flsenate.gov/Session/Bill/2026/808
- Florida Statutes, Section 627.0629 (windstorm mitigation discounts): flsenate.gov/Laws/Statutes/2025/627.0629
- Citizens Property Insurance Corporation, “Uniform Mitigation Verification Inspection Form Changes” (March 19, 2026): citizensfla.com/-/20260319-uniform-mitigation-verification-i…
Own land in Southwest Florida?
Our team can tell you what your parcel can become. Call (239) 321-0594 or start a land review online.
Start a land review


